Annotations and key words of the articles of the Bulletin № 2 (40)/2026


№ Initials and surname of the autor (s) Article title Annotation Keywords
1

Amurtayeva Dinara Talgatovna

Shidemov Azamat Garifullaevich

PROBLEMS OF THE PRACTICE OF APPLYING ELECTRONIC TRACKING TOOLS TO PERSONS REGISTERED WITH THE PROBATION SERVICE IN THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTANThe article discusses the use of electronic tracking devices in relation to persons registered with the
probation service in the Republic of Kazakhstan. The article analyzes the legal basis for the use of electronic monitoring, the
practice of its application and emerging problems of an organizational, technical and legal nature. It is noted that electronic
control is one of the effective tools of modern criminal policy aimed at expanding the use of alternative penalties not related
to imprisonment. At the same time, the introduction of electronic tracking tools is accompanied by a number of difficulties
related to insufficient regulation of certain procedures in legislation, technical infrastructure, and limited logistical resources.
The article formulates proposals aimed at improving legal regulation and increasing the effectiveness of electronic monitoring
in the probation system.
probation; electronic monitoring; electronic tracking devices; wristband; penal enforcement system; criminal policy; probation service; poduchny.
2

Batyrbekova Balnur Karimbayevna

Asemgul Uzakbayevna Usenbayeva

UNIVERSALISM AND CULTURAL RELATIVISM OF HUMAN RIGHTS: A COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS OF THE PRACTICE OF INTERNATIONAL AND REGIONAL JUDICIAL BODIESThis article examines the relationship between the universalism of human rights and cultural relativism in
the practice of international and regional judicial bodies. Based on a comparative legal analysis, the study explores the
activities of the European Court of Human Rights, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, the International Court of
Justice of the United Nations, as well as international criminal tribunals and the International Criminal Court. The findings
demonstrate that universalism constitutes the fundamental basis of the international human rights protection system, ensuring
the inviolability of core standards, including the right to life, the prohibition of torture, non-discrimination, and other
peremptory norms of international law. At the same time, regional judicial bodies have developed different approaches to
incorporating cultural context, ranging from «culturally sensitive universalism» in the European system to «culturally
oriented universalism» in the Inter-American framework. International criminal courts and the International Court of Justice
adhere to a stricter model of universalism, under which cultural and historical considerations cannot limit the application of
fundamental legal norms. The analysis reveals an emerging multi-level model of legal implementation in which universal
standards are combined with due consideration of cultural diversity.
human rights; universalism; cultural relativism; international courts; European Court of Human Rights; Inter-American Court of Human Rights; International Court of Justice; international criminal law.
3

Zhempiissov Nazarbek Sharuanovich

INTERNATIONAL LEGAL STANDARDS FOR ENSURING ECONOMIC SECURITY AND THEIR IMPACT ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF CRIMINAL LAW OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTANThe article provides a comparative legal analysis of international legal standards for ensuring economic
security and examines their impact on the development of specific norms of the criminal law of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
In the course of the research, the author has examined the opinions of domestic and foreign scholars addressing this
issue and conducted a comparative legal analysis of international legal standards for ensuring economic security, including
the fight against corruption. The analysis aims to determine their influence on the evolution of the criminal law and
legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, including the formulation of specific provisions within the Criminal Code
concerning liability for criminal offenses in the sphere of economic activity and also for some corrupt criminal offenses.
Based on the results of the analysis, the author formulates conclusions and proposals directed toward the forwardlooking and consistent implementation of a number of progressive ideas and norms of international legal standards, alongside
successful foreign legal experience, into national legislation through the phased transformation of the state's economic
security system.
economic security; international standard; convention; Criminal Code; implementation; money laundering; transnational crime; financial transparency and control.
4

Ibragimova Flyura Galimovna

LEGAL ASPECTS OF DEFENSIVE MEDICINE PRACTICE: A SCIENTIFIC AND LEGAL ANALYSIS.This article analyzes, from a scientific and legal perspective, the nature of defensive medicine, the reasons
for its emergence, and the characteristics of its prevalence in the modern healthcare system. The study examines the impact of
defensive medicine on clinical decision-making, the extent of physicians’ excessive caution driven by legal liability, and its
effect on the quality of medical care. In addition, the legal, social, organizational, and psychological factors influencing the
prevalence of this phenomenon are comprehensively examined.
The methodological basis of the study consists of a set of scientific and legal analysis methods; to reveal the essence
of defensive medicine, a review of domestic and foreign scientific literature was conducted. Based on an analysis of the
regulatory framework of the Republic of Kazakhstan and other countries, as well as a study of international experience, the
prevalence of defensive medicine is assessed.
The results of the study justify the need to implement legal and organizational measures aimed at reducing the
prevalence of defensive medicine.
defensive medicine; healthcare professional; patient; doctor; healthcare organization; responsibility; medical care; medical service.
5

Kairulla Yerkin Kairullovich

INTERNET FRAUD WITHIN THE FRAMEWORK OF MODERN CYBERCRIME AND SCIENTIFIC APPROACHES TO ITS STUDYThe article examines fraud as one of the most widespread forms of cybercrime. It analyzes the main
foreign and domestic scientific approaches to defining the place of fraud within the system of cybercrime. Special attention is
given to the phenomenon of social engineering, the victimological features of cyber‑fraud, and its interdisciplinary nature. It
is argued that the digital environment has not changed the essence of fraud as deception and abuse of trust, but it has radically
transformed its scale, methods of execution, mechanisms of impact on the victim, and the level of latency. The conclusion is
that modern fraud should be viewed as a self‑serving act that combines elements of a property crime, informational tort, and
socio‑psychological impact on the victim.
cybercrime; cyberfraud; fraud; social engineering; victimology; crimes against property
6

Kaliyev Askar Abuzhanovich

Kuzhakhmetova Kaldygul Sirgalievna

CRIMINAL LAW ASPECTS OF PREVENTING FRAUD COMMITTED USING INFORMATION AND TELECOMMUNICATION TECHNOLOGIESThe article examines criminal law mechanisms for preventing fraud committed through information and
telecommunication technologies. The purpose of the study is to identify the legal nature of digital fraud and to determine the
role of criminal legislation, law enforcement practice, and organizational interaction of law enforcement agencies in its
prevention. The research is based on formal legal, comparative legal, systemic, and doctrinal methods. The author argues that
although the classic features of fraud remain unchanged in the digital environment, prevention becomes more difficult
because of new methods of deception, specific ways of influencing victims, the electronic nature of evidence, and the
transnational component of such acts. The study proposes clarifying legal qualification, improving procedures for securing
digital traces, strengthening early victim protection, enhancing cooperation with banks and online platforms, and
systematizing information-analytical work.
digital evidence; phishing; social engineering; legal qualification; information system; cybersecurity; sanction; prevention; law enforcement.
7

Kozhabekov Dauren Meirkhanovich

THE CONCEPT AND SIGNS OF AN ORGANIZED GROUP IN MODERN CONDITIONS OF DIGITAL CRIME DEVELOPMENTThe article examines the criminal law concept of an organized group in the context of the development of
digital crime. It considers modern forms of organized criminal activity based on the use of information and communication
technologies, digital platforms, and anonymous means of interaction. The criminal legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan
and several foreign countries regulating the characteristics of an organized group is analyzed. The study substantiated the
need for a comprehensive assessment of such systemic characteristics of an organized group as the continuity of criminal
activity, the stability and number of participants, the clear coordination of their actions, and the ability to use digital
technologies to achieve criminal goals. The necessity of assessing stability through the group's ability to ensure the continuity
of criminal activity, coordinate the actions of its participants, and use digital technologies to achieve criminal objectives is
substantiated. Based on the findings, proposals are formulated to improve the judicial interpretation of the characteristics of
an organized group under modern conditions.
organized crime; transnational organized crime; organized group; criminal group; sustainability of organized group; cyberspace.
8

Kulkeev Elmir Uristemovich

PUBLIC PROSECUTION IN KAZAKHSTAN: PROBLEMS OF INSTITUTIONAL REFORMThe article examines institutional and procedural problems of public prosecution in Kazakhstan in the
context of adversarial proceedings, the presumption of innocence, procedural fairness and the protection of human rights. The
purpose of the study is to develop a scientifically grounded model for improving the status of the public prosecutor and the
organizational foundations of courtroom prosecution. The methodological basis includes formal-legal, comparative-legal and
systemic methods, analysis of the current legislation of the Republic of Kazakhstan, foreign and post-Soviet experience,
international standards, as well as scholarly and expert sources. It is substantiated that the existing model combines the
prosecutor’s procedural duty to act objectively with organizational dependence on the general prosecutorial hierarchy. The
study proposes a specialized vertical of public prosecutors, a collegial mechanism for resolving disagreements, a written
procedure for changing the prosecutorial position and safeguards aimed at reducing accusatory bias and improving the quality
of public prosecution.
сourtroom prosecution; autonomy; adversarial proceedings; conflict; trial stage.
9

Kurmanalina Assel Muratovna

AUTOMATION OF ALIMONY COLLECTION PROCESSES: PROSPECTS FOR THE USE OF ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCEThe article discusses the prospects for the introduction of artificial intelligence technologies in the
processes of alimony recovery in the Republic of Kazakhstan. The study is based on an analysis of international regulations,
scientific publications, as well as the works of foreign authors reflecting the concepts of digitalization of justice and
automation of law enforcement procedures.
The author substantiates the need to form a comprehensive digital system of enforcement proceedings that integrates
interdepartmental databases and intelligent forecasting algorithms. The potential advantages and risks of using artificial
intelligence, as well as possible threats to the principles of legality and justice, are shown.
In conclusion, proposals are formulated to improve regulatory regulation, ethical standards, and organizational and
technical mechanisms for the introduction of artificial intelligence into the enforcement of court decisions.
artificial intelligence; enforcement proceedings; alimony recovery; automation; effectiveness of law enforcement; forecasting; ethical standards; digital transformation
10

Lakbayev Kanat Sametovich

Arenova Leila Klimentievna

CYBERCRIME STATISTICS: «GROWING PAINS» OR A SYSTEMIC PROBLEM?The present article analyze key impediments of collating official criminal statistics related to criminal
offenses unified by the conception of “cybercrime”. A long-term analysis of their dynamics over five years exposed numerous
of discrepancies that adversely affect the analysis of the criminogenic risk assessments in this area. Inter alia, this is the
informational deficiency on certain infractions. Additionally, there is a lack of information in criminal statistics on a range of
offenses that evince the existing conditions in crucial sectors, including larceny and drug-related violations. Analogous
depiction arise with regard to promotion of hostility, public calls for the coup d'état and separatism. Aforementioned unlawful
acts are primarily dedicated in the information ecosystem and utilizing new technologies. Drawing from the preceding, it is
proposed to supplement official statistics with these important indicators.
cybercrime; law enforcement; criminal statistics; information technology and communications; the Internet; information тechnology
11

Makhanov Talgat Gabitovich

Myrzabaуev Nurlanali Koshkaruly

SCIENTIFIC AND PRACTICAL ANALYSIS OF INTERNET FRAUDSTER DIALOGUES USING PSYCHOLOGICAL AND NEURO-LINGUISTIC PROGRAMMING TOOLSThe article analyzes the dialogues of Internet scammers from the perspective of psycholinguistics, neurolinguistic programming and criminology. The relevance of the study is due to the rapid growth of cybercrimes committed by
social engineering methods that pose a threat to national security. The empirical base consisted of 530 audio recordings of
telephone conversations between intruders and Anti-Call Center operators (with a total duration of more than 105 hours).
Methodologically, the work is based on discourse analysis, content analysis, and a structural and functional approach. As a
result, key manipulative patterns were identified: strategies for establishing authority through imitation of official status and
professional jargon; psychological triggers of scarcity, fear, and gratuitousness; reframing techniques for receiving SMS
codes; techniques for inducing a trance state and emotional swings. The methods of victim resistance are analyzed separately
– logical audit, humor and bringing to the point of absurdity. The foreign experience of regulating AI and synthetic content
(EU, UK, Singapore, China, India) is considered. Practical recommendations are formulated for citizens, law enforcement
agencies, banks and developers of digital security systems.
Internet fraud; social engineering; neuro-linguistic programming; manipulative strategie; deepfake; cognitive immunity; digital security.
12

Rabayev Daulet Kumarbekovich

Nurkenova Madina K.

ORGANIZING THE EMPLOYMENT OF CONVICTS IN MINIMUM-SECURITY INSTITUTIONS: PROBLEMS, RISKS AND AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENTThe article examines educational work with convicts held in minimum-security institutions of the
Republic of Kazakhstan, including those actually involved in labour activities. It argues that minimum security is not limited
to a less restrictive regime, but also places a special burden on targeted support, since employed convicts more often interact
with employers, social networks and the external environment. Based on legislation, departmental empirical data and
scholarly approaches, the article substantiates the need to link educational influence with risk assessment, stable law-abiding
behaviour and resocialization. It is noted that a formal count of activities does not show their preventive value unless the
causes of violations and behavioural dynamics are considered. The article proposes clarifying departmental rules,
strengthening interagency cooperation, applying elements of dynamic security and introducing individual support
programmes aimed at public safety.
educational work; minimum security; employed convicts; targeted support; risk assessment; law-abiding behaviour; resocialization; dynamic security; interagency cooperation; public safety.
13

Ryskulbekova Balzhan Rashitovna

Zhaksymbetov Bakitzhan Parmeshovich

DIGITAL EVIDENCE IN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS: KAZAKHSTAN AND THE EUROPEANThe article examines the features of the legal regulation of digital evidence in criminal proceedings in the
Republic of Kazakhstan and the European Union. The relevance of the topic is driven by the growing level of cybercrime and
the increasing use of electronic data in criminal investigations. The legal nature of digital evidence, its role in the system of
proof, as well as the procedures for collection, fixation, and evaluation in criminal proceedings are analyzed. The study
compares Kazakhstan’s approach, based on general provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code and flexible law enforcement
practice, with the European Union’s model characterized by detailed regulation and standardization. Issues of legal
uncertainty, technical capacity, and cross-border access to data are identified. The study concludes with recommendations on
improving national legislation, strengthening procedural safeguards, and introducing unified standards for handling digital
evidence.
digital evidence; Criminal Procedure Code; analysis; European model; law; procedure; regulation.
14

Sarsenova Ainur Zheksenbaevna

Bekturganov Abdimanap Elikbayevich

LEGAL PROBLEMS OF ENVIRONMENTAL EXPERTISE IN THE JUDICIAL PROCESS OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTANThe article examines the issues of legal support for environmental expertise within the judicial system of the
Republic of Kazakhstan. The aim of the study is to conduct a comprehensive analysis of the legal mechanisms governing the
use of environmental expertise in judicial proceedings and to develop proposals for improving its legal regulation. The study
identifies key problems within the current legal framework of environmental expertise and analyzes their impact on judicial
practice. Among the main challenges are the fragmentation and inconsistency of regulatory legal acts, the insufficiently
defined professional status and liability of experts, the ambiguity of procedural rules, and the institutional weakness of the
independent expert institution. The scientific novelty of the research lies in developing a conceptual approach to improving
the legal regulation of judicial environmental expertise based on a comparative legal analysis of international practices and
the national regulatory model. The research employs system-structural, comparative legal, and empirical methods, enabling a
comparative assessment of foreign experience and Kazakhstan’s judicial practice. As a result, several practical
recommendations are proposed, including the systematization of the regulatory framework, clarification of the legal status of
experts, improvement of professional certification and accreditation mechanisms, the introduction of unified methodological
standards for conducting expert examinations, and the digitalization of expert procedures. The implementation of these
measures will contribute to more effective resolution of environmental disputes, strengthening environmental safety, and
improving the quality of justice.
judicial environmental expertise; regulatory legal framework; status of experts; independence of expertise; environmental disputes; digital technologies; international standard; environmental law
15

Seisekenova Ainash

Taishyk Arailym

THE YOUNG GENERATION'S PERCEPTION OF SUCCESS AND HUMANITY: A STUDY BASED ON STUDENTS OF LAW AND PHILOLOGYThe purpose of the study is to determine the understanding of the life success of a person among
Generation Z students studying at the university and its relationship with ethical norms. Accordingly, the study used
questionnaires and data and document analysis methods. The study was conducted among students of two different
specialties: law and philological sciences. The results show that while law students value qualities related to a person's socio economic status and attitude to work, philological students attach more importance to a person's moral and emotional qualities and their manifestation in action. Young students continue to adhere to traditional cultural values and consider them important for achieving success. However, the established views are not stable, and the adaptation of young people of this generation to life may change depending on their professional and living environment.
life success; values; generation Z; student; morality; association method; legal consciousness; socioeconomic status; legal culture
16

Sekenov Dastan Abdykadyrovich

Mukanov Daniyar Zhumagatovich

PROBLEMS OF IMPLEMENTING LAW ENFORCEMENT FUNCTIONS BY THE MILITARY POLICE OF THE ARMED FORCES OF THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKHSTANThe article examines the problems of implementing law enforcement functions by the military police of
the Armed Forces of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Based on a functional analysis, the author studies the legal status,
competence, and practical activities of military police bodies.
Particular attention is paid to the issues of duplication of powers with military command bodies, performance of
non-core functions, insufficient effectiveness of preventive activities, and inconsistency between the organizational structure
and the objectives of maintaining law and order in the armed forces. The article analyzes the impact of these factors on
military discipline, crime prevention, and the implementation of law enforcement powers.
Problems of legal regulation, methodological support, and the absence of a risk-oriented prevention model are also
considered. The author concludes that it is necessary to strengthen the law enforcement specialization of military police
bodies and improve the preventive model of maintaining military law and order.
military police; military law and order; military security; functional analysis; law enforcement activity; military criminal offenses; prevention; Armed Forces of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
17

Soroceanu Igor

Cojocaru Radion

LEGAL-CRIMINAL ANALYSIS OF CRIMES RELATED TO MERCENARY ACTIVITY, ANALYSIS ACCORDING TO THE CRIMINAL CODE OF THE REPUBLIC OF MOLDOVAThe activity of mercenaries constitutes a serious criminal phenomenon that directly endangers the peace,
stability, and security of the international community. Mercenaries are individuals who, by engaging in armed conflict for
private gain, acquire a particular legal status that subjects them to criminal liability. Their involvement is prohibited under the
legislation of most states, as well as under key international legal instruments, precisely because such actions undermine
lawful military structures, fuel conflicts, and jeopardize fundamental human rights.
Given the complexity and gravity of this issue, the present study sets out as its main objective a comprehensive
juridical-criminal analysis of offenses connected to mercenary activity. This includes examining the legal definitions, the
constitutive elements of such crimes, the forms of participation, as well as the measures adopted at both national and
international levels to prevent, sanction, and combat mercenarism.
armed conflict; training mercenaries; criminal law; military actions; hiring mercenaries; normative modalitie; integrity; financing mercenaries.
18

Taubayeva Gulfarida

OFFICIAL CRIMES IN THE FIELD OF PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AS A METHOD OF EMBEZZLING BUDGET FUNDS: ISSUES OF DETECTION AND PROOFThe article examines official crimes in the field of public procurement as a latent economic and legal
mechanism for embezzling budget funds, implemented through formally lawful procurement procedures. It is substantiated
that such crimes are not limited to isolated violations of tender rules, but constitute a prearranged system of managerial
decisions aimed at redistributing public finances in favor of affiliated or controlled entities. Based on the analysis of pre-trial
investigation materials, judicial practice and supervisory findings, the article identifies typical schemes of restricting
competition, artificial splitting of procurements, tailoring technical specifications to a predetermined supplier, unjustified
overpricing of goods, works and services, and fictitious performance of public contracts. Special attention is paid to
evidentiary problems arising from the high degree of formalization of procurement activities, the masking of criminal intent
as business expediency and the need to identify actual beneficiaries. The article formulates proposals aimed at improving the
tactics of detecting and proving embezzlement of budget funds in public procurement, including early analysis of managerial
decisions, financial flows, affiliation of participants and the actual results of contract performance.
рublic procurement; budget funds; official crime; embezzlement; abuse of official authority; proof.
19

Tusupov Kairakbay Kenesovich

IMPROVING MECHANISMS FOR THE USE OF CONFISCATED PROPERTY: A COMPARATIVE LEGAL ANALYSIS AND PROSPECTS FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF LEGISLATION IN THE REPUBLIC OF KAZAKSTANThe article examines the legal mechanisms for use of confiscated property and proceeds from its sale in
foreign countries and analyzes prospects for improving the relevant institution in the Republic of Kazakhstan. Using a
comparative legal analysis, models for managing confiscated assets in neighboring and non-CIS countries are examined.
Particular attention is paid to legal systems where legislation provides for the allocation of a portion of confiscated assets to
the development of the material and technical base of law enforcement agencies. A scientific discussion was held regarding
the admissibility of funding law enforcement activities with confiscated funds. The need for a centralized system for
recording confiscated property and special fund for confiscated assets in the Republic of Kazakhstan was substantiated.
Proposals for improving national legislation were developed.
use of confiscated property; fight against crime; obtained by criminal means; special fund; funding of law enforcement agencies; employee incentives.


Назад